This report by two California attorneys describes in detail the proven mechanisms that local governments have used to protect long-term affordability of below market-rate homeownership units. The report includes case studies of successful litigation over the enforcement of affordable homeownership restrictions. View Report
Almost all jurisdictions require developers to execute some form of developer agreement. These agreements generally specify in detail how the inclusionary obligations will be met, which units will be designated as units meeting the requirements, and how construction and marketing of those units will be phased.
In some instances, development agreements are standalone documents. In many instances, they take the form an affordable housing plan attached as an exhibit to a master development agreement. In most but not all jurisdictions, inclusionary-related development agreements are recorded against title.
Despite the fact that almost all jurisdictions use developer agreements, most programs don’t rely on these agreements for enforcement of inclusionary requirements. Instead, jurisdictions use the issuance of building permits and/or occupancy permits as a way of enforcing inclusionary obligations.
In addition, many programs regularly inspect development projects under construction to ensure that inclusionary obligations are being met. Jurisdictions generally will issue the builder successive building permits only if the builder has passed these periodic inspections. The jurisdiction may also not issue occupancy permits until the builder has met the inclusionary obligations.
PolicyLink* describes how the City of Salinas, “provides developers with sample Affordable Housing Plans for either ownership or rental projects. Each template includes a description of the project and a proposal describing how the developer will satisfy the city’s inclusionary requirements including:
- The percentage of total housing units that will be affordable
- The mix of income levels that will be able to afford the units
- The affordable rents or prices
- The unit sizes and number of bedrooms of affordable units
- A description of the comparability of affordable and market units in terms of size and amenities
- A map of unit locations within the project
- A schedule for completion and sale or leasing of the affordable units relative to market rate units
- A description of the mechanisms that will be used to preserve affordability of ownership units
- A plan for marketing the units and criteria to be used for selection of residents.
According to PolicyLink: “Developers in Salinas must submit these plans along with their first application for planning approval for any new residential project covered by the towns inclusionary ordinance. The affordable housing plan is then considered along with other project plans and approved by either the planning commission or city council depending on the project. Once the terms of this plan are approved, the key provisions are incorporated into an affordable housing agreement that is recorded against the property prior to subdivision of the property or approval of any building permits.”
Delivering on the Promise of Inclusionary Housing Policies: Best Practices in Administration and Monitoring
Inclusionary housing programs require a certain level of ongoing administration and oversight in order to effectively produce and preserve affordable housing opportunities. This paper outlines several of the common tasks associated with ongoing administration of inclusionary housing programs and describes some of the approaches to staffing and paying for their implementation. The paper also provides an overview of the choices that have the greatest impact on the jurisdiction’s administrative workload. View Paper